Operator Ledger

Over 200 businesses urge EU to rethink tobacco rules

By Ella Fletcher
·
Share:
Tobacco control activists protest.
Tobacco control activists protest.

Over 200 businesses have appealed to European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, urging a reevaluation of the EU’s tobacco regulations. They caution that tighter rules might negatively impact Europe’s economy. This diverse group, including retailers, farmers, hospitality providers, and manufacturers, seeks a full analysis of how changes to the Tobacco Products Directive and Tobacco Advertising Directive could affect the economy and society. They stress that public health goals and European competitiveness should be aligned, not in conflict.

Employment and Rural Impact

Representing various sectors of the tobacco and nicotine industry, the signatories argue that public health measures should not undermine Europe’s competitive edge. They highlight a 2023 S&P Global Market Intelligence study, which shows the industry supports over 1.5 million jobs and contributes more than €107 billion annually in taxes and VAT. However, they acknowledge these figures reflect the industry’s overall impact, not the specific effects of any regulatory changes.

Small businesses and agricultural communities are at the heart of the coalition’s concerns. Peter van der Mark, from the European Smoking Tobacco Association, points out that many members are small, family-run enterprises struggling with ongoing costs and uncertainty. Przemysław Noworyta, representing European tobacco growers, warns that decisions made in Brussels could significantly affect farming families and rural areas already facing challenges.

Engagement and Compliance

Tobacco Europe, representing major manufacturers like British American Tobacco, JT International, and Imperial Brands, clarifies that the coalition does not oppose public health goals. “We are not asking the Commission to abandon its public health ambitions. We are asking it to listen, follow its own rules and get this right,” stated Nathalie Darge, the organization’s secretary general. This appeal comes as Brussels reviews tobacco regulations in light of new nicotine products. The Commission’s April assessment confirmed that current rules have reduced smoking and related deaths but identified new challenges, especially among youth.

The coalition also raises concerns about the review process, noting negative feedback from the Regulatory Scrutiny Board on the Commission’s 2026 impact assessment and earlier evaluations. They emphasize the issue of illegal trade, urging the Commission to focus on enforcement. The group warns that stricter rules might push consumers toward illegal sources. A September report from the European Court of Auditors estimated illicit tobacco costs €13 billion annually in lost revenue, though it also noted a lack of reliable data on the market’s size and impact.

Public health remains a critical issue, with the Commission citing tobacco as the EU’s leading preventable health risk, causing nearly 700,000 deaths each year. The coalition offers to collaborate with the Commission on a balanced, evidence-based approach.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *