Licensing Watch

Audit Reveals GMI Mismanagement, Payments to Ineligible Recipients

By Ella Fletcher
·
Share:
Audit Reveals GMI Mismanagement, Payments to Ineligible Recipients - gmi mismanagement
The Audit Office report highlights tens of thousands of euros paid to ineligible GMI recipients. Photo: nattanan23/Pixabay

A special report by the Audit Office exposes severe shortcomings in the management of the Guaranteed Minimum Income (GMI) and disbursements of thousands of euros to ineligible recipients. The report highlights instances of tens of thousands of euros paid out to ineligible recipients, applications lingering under “pre-approval” status for up to 10 years, and inadequate monitoring of bank deposits and real estate holdings.

Pre-approval, as noted in the report, was instituted as an emergency, provisional financial relief measure, typically lasting three months until the formal evaluation of an application is completed. However, the audit revealed that it transformed into an entrenched practice of disbursing allowances for consecutive years.

Years of Delays and Ineligible Recipients

In 150 cases, representing 60%, GMI payments under pre-approval status exceeded two years. In only 10 cases, just 4%, was the initial three-month timeframe respected.

An examination of 11 pre-approval cases showed payouts varying from €21,887 to €131,973 per applicant, with durations spanning 57 to 129 months—sometimes reaching ten years. For example, one person collected €102,528 in GMI from 2017 through 2024 (87 months total).

Another instance involved €80,607 paid over 83 months before payments stopped in 2024 due to misleading statements and evidence the person had voluntarily quit work.

Read Also: Cyprus Customs Announces Auction of Vehicles, Boats, and Antiques

Bypassing Criteria and Bank Deposits

Eligibility for GMI requires applicants to have bank deposits of at least €5,000, with an additional €1,000 allowed for each family member. Exceptions can be made for sums like accident settlements or medical funds up to €20,000. When reviewing 737 cases, investigators found that in 587 (79.6%), deposits fell between €5,000 and €20,000.

In 131 cases (17.8%), deposits ranged from €20,000 to €100,000, while 19 cases (2.6%) showed balances exceeding €100,000. The audit also pinpointed 11 instances where deposits were unusually high, between €160,000 and €680,000.

Additionally, in four other cases of applicants with deposits between €296,000 and €439,000, exemptions were approved without locating or obtaining the necessary supporting documentation to substantiate the origin of funds, such as accident compensation, at the time of the review. Another applicant received €90,839 in GMI while maintaining €439,611 in deposits, without any verification in the system regarding the source of the funds.

The Deputy Ministry of Social Welfare cites past employee departures as the reason for past delays, claiming processing times and backlogs have since improved. However, the audit uncovered persistent IT system failures, poor bank data integration, and chronic understaffing in the complaint investigations unit.

The Audit Office states that property ownership limits cap at €100,000, excluding a primary home up to 300 square meters. Among nine cases with the highest property values, ranging from €132,450 to €811,400, benefits paid per case varied from €24,433 to €159,660.

Read Also: Over 200 businesses urge EU to rethink tobacco rules

An applicant owning real estate valued at €150,767 in 2013 saw the property revalued in 2018 at €210,400. Despite an alert logged in the system in 2022, the application was not reviewed promptly, and the applicant continued to receive GMI until 2025 (amounting to a total of €24,433), while indications also suggest the individual was not residing permanently in Cyprus, and was found to have €439,611 in deposits.

Administrative dysfunctions were also identified in the management of complaint investigations. The Audit Team, established in 2023, had three of its four members resign by 2026 without being replaced, leaving the unit severely understaffed.

The digital system used to archive documents was found to be flawed, with documents archived based on the date of scanning rather than submission date. Additionally, files were found misfiled inside the folders of other applicants, further highlighting the need for improved administrative practices.

Response and Recommendations

The Auditor General, Andreas Papaconstantinou, stressed that the shortcomings create an raised risk of dispersing public funds to individuals who are not genuinely eligible. The AO recommends the immediate establishment of strict re-examination mechanisms and full integration across IT systems to address these issues.

The Deputy Ministry of Social Welfare has already taken steps to address the issues, including the establishment of a Complaints Registry and the reduction of pending pre-approvals from 252 to 149 in January 2026. The average processing time for new applications has also dropped sharply to 61 calendar days.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *